10 minutes
Justice — disparity is not automatically discrimination The gaps are large and measured. Cause is contested. Both sentences can be true.
What you’ll be able to do Identify the practical implication of “Justice — disparity is not automatically discrimination” and apply it to one live DHS decision connected to The Record. Compare the responses to this question and explain your choice: How should the team use the concept? Document a next step for Justice — disparity is not automatically discrimination: Choose one live work object, name a change or formal escalation, assign an owner, and set the date the result will be reviewed. Michelle Alexander’s The New Jim Crow is a popular interpretation. BJS and the Sentencing Project are the counts. Keep them labeled.
BJS, Prisoners in 2022: about 32% of sentenced state and federal prisoners were Black. Black Americans are about 14% of the U.S. population. The Sentencing Project’s U.S. imprisonment-rate ratio is about 4.8 to 1, Black to white. A gap is a disparity. The discipline Undisputed: the U.S. incarcerates a larger share of its people than almost any nation; Black Americans are imprisoned at several times the white rate. Contested: how much of that is differences in offending versus differences in who is policed, stopped, charged, sentenced. Honest researchers say both, in proportions people argue about.
Where the system is well documented: discretionary points such as drug enforcement, where usage is similar across groups and arrest is not. You can accept the disparity without settling the full causal story. Disparity is an observation. Discrimination is a causal claim. Good scholarship does not collapse them.
In this lesson you will Read a population-versus-prison chart without turning it into a verdict.
Keep Alexander as interpretation and BJS as count.
See Minnesota’s child-welfare numbers as DHS’s own house — still as disparity until cause is shown.
Minnesota DHS child-welfare reporting as publicly summarized for 2023 (DHS-5408PA-ENG): Black and Hispanic youth about twice as likely as white children to be in out-of-home care; American Indian / Native youth about sixteen times as likely. ICWA is a government-to-government path, not a diversity module. A sixteen-times gap in your own agency’s data is not “national politics.” It is a Minnesota human-services outcome. Cause still has to be argued. The number does not get to be ignored.
DHS close — your turn If your administration has a racial breakout, write the last number you actually saw — or write that you have not seen one.
Disparity or discrimination: which word fits that number today, and what would you still need to say the other?
Put this lesson to work What you can change You control whether justice — disparity is not automatically discrimination changes a live DHS process connected to The Record or remains information on a page.
What to watch for The team completes the learning, keeps the same default, assigns no owner, and never checks who carries the burden.
Your next step Choose one live work object, name a change or formal escalation, assign an owner, and set the date the result will be reviewed.
Carry this forward The gaps are large and measured. Cause is contested. Both sentences can be true.
You control whether justice — disparity is not automatically discrimination changes a live DHS process connected to The Record or remains information on a page.
Choose one live work object, name a change or formal escalation, assign an owner, and set the date the result will be reviewed.
Completion is shown by a scenario decision, a knowledge-check response and a saved one-minute commitment.
Choose one live work object, name a change or formal escalation, assign an owner, and set the date the result will be reviewed.
Browse and download only. Course notes are not typed or saved on this page.
Reset this lesson
Previous lesson Next lesson Participation and course completion in this program do not count toward DHS-required training credits unless management, a director, or DHS leadership expressly approves an exception.
